School Library Journal

For 12-year-old Alice, swimming is her life, especially this summer since it’s the only thing that hasn’t changed. A serious car accident has left her mother homebound and their family scattered, living in four different places. In protest, Alice refuses to sleep in her home until the family is reunited, choosing instead to inhabit the backyard in the family’s old tent. Late one evening she meets the new next-door neighbor, a young girl named Piper who does not speak. Soon Alice starts babysitting Piper and is surprised when she hears Piper speak—but no one believes her. With the help of a new friend, Harriet, and Piper’s older half-brother, Owen, Alice sets out to prove that Piper isn’t so silent after all. Alice is a strong, self-driven girl determined to excel in a sport underrepresented in children’s fiction. The descriptions of swimming events are vivid and authentic, but, unfortunately, that does not extend to much of the dialogue, plot points, and characters. One-dimensional, absentee adults abound. Despite this, Diehl possesses real potential as a middle grade writer with descriptive imagery that can be quite beautiful at times. VERDICT An interesting, if uneven, story. A secondary purchase for most libraries.—Rebecca Gueorguiev, New York Public Library